Dear Erin,
My daughter has been coming home from school with all
sorts of information about the birds and the bees that she didn't get from us.
Eventually, we learned that one of her 2nd grade classmates has been
"enlightening" the class with information that is at best exaggerated
-- at worst, completely invented. After complaints from parents, the
teachers tried to intervene. The child and his parents denied
responsibility. They claim their child doesn't know anything about sex to
begin with as they "haven't had that conversation with him yet."
What can we do to protect our child and get this to stop?
Signed,
TMI
Dear TMI:
Kids say the darndest things. Most of the time, their misguided utterances seem
pretty harmless. Consider this jumble of misinformation that my kids brought
home this year: 1) Taylor Swift has had 500 boyfriends, 2) North Korea is going to start a world war
(and win), 3) Women can’t
vote, 4) Guinea pigs are cannibals, and 5)
Someone’s uncle is making a movie about their recess game.
When kids get stuff wrong, parents can
usually just straighten them out.
My personal responses to those fact
nuggets, for example, were pretty simple:
1)Wrong.
2)Wrong. 3) Sexist and Wrong. 4) Maybe.
5) Um. No. Creepy.
What I can’t tell from your letter is if
little Billy Birds and Bees is harmless, or outright offensive. I mean, if the kid is going beyond bad facts –
e.g. Taylor Swift is a sexual cannibal, or my uncle gave birth to a
guinea pig – to details about human sexuality that are violent, graphic, or terribly
age-inappropriate, then those parents were right to enlist the help of teachers. In extreme cases, a school should probably
respond with age-appropriate sanctions.
Since you used the word protect, though, perhaps you don’t find the kid so harmless. Perhaps it bothers
your daughter to hear this graphic dialogue. If the other parents are defensive, or in
denial -- and the school refuses to challenge them -- parents like you are left
to wonder how you can stop the sex, lies, and inaccuracy on your own.
I assume you’ve already told your
daughter that this lad is an unreliable informant. We can’t control the crazy of other parents,
the crazy of their kids, or the inaction of authorities. But we can exert some control over our
children’s personal filters. We can urge
our children to report unsolicited rumors to us, then help them fact check, in
the privacy of our own homes. Will that
be enough for you? Maybe. Perhaps Billy just has
a mysterious and untreated hormone imbalance.
Once he stops eating soy, maybe he’ll stop acting out, and start having
whatever conversation it is, that his parents think they've already had.
Or maybe that won’t be enough. Maybe his chatty ways are still
bothering your daughter, or disrupting her education, or presenting her with
concepts she isn't old enough to filter. In that case, I can offer this potentially relevant story.
Many years ago, I took a job in an
office, and was placed on a team with several men who were predisposed to sexual
banter. They talked about their sex
lives. They asked about mine. They commented
on my looks. I tried to make it clear that, uh, I
was busy working. A few months into this
job, I couldn’t take it anymore. I
told my supervisor that they were disrupting my ability to do my job.
My supervisor told me that legally, I could
file a complaint. I could escalate it
through "proper channels."
Practically, though, this wasn’t likely to accomplish much. My colleagues might be reprimanded. I’d have
to confront them more publicly. And since
I still might have to work with them, this might be a bad outcome. For me. Instead, he suggested I simply ask them to stop. I’ve tried that, I protested. Try it again, he said. This time, don’t smile. Don’t sound friendly. Look them in the eyes. Tell them you need it to stop. Immediately.
And you know, it was great advice. I think of myself as a fairly brazen
chick. But really, I hadn’t even realized how
much I undermined my own message – in a stereotypically female way, I suppose -- through facial
expressions, verbal cues, and body language. Ultimately, was I a bad feminist for failing to escalate
through proper channels? I don’t know. Maybe.
In any case, that's not the issue we're debating here. But more to the point, it totally worked! It didn’t force a big legal thing. Or make anyone
defensive. It just delivered the best
outcome.
I don’t know how relevant this story is
to your conundrum. I just know that oftentimes, the proper channels can’t protect us. Or our kids. If ignoring, and correcting, and legally
escalating hasn’t fixed the problem to your satisfaction, maybe it’s time to
empower your daughter to just let Billy have it. To tell him she’s wise to his lies. That his teaching style isn’t working for
her. That she’s dropping his class. Shut the kid down.
It’s nice to be nice. Especially on the playground. But sometimes the best outcome is to stop getting
along, and start speaking the truth to crazy. Good luck.